I think that the Lightning does have a specific leather pattern.....the leater wrap with the little holes in it. Standard F-Series leather wheels are smooth leather and maybe a tad bit thinner overall.
I've got an NOS on that I may sell, but it's for a '94 (with airbag).
Search the Gen1 archives and you'll find a good alternative to a new wheel if all that's wrong with it is just the leather peeling away. There is a place I think called American Stitches that will re-wrap the leather and restore your wheel back to original for pretty reasonable cost.
Later,
------------------
- Kevin
Black '94 #907