The National Lightning Owners Club Inc The National Lightning Owners Club Inc
 
Home |  Classified Ads |  Gallery |  Join the Club |  Register on the Forum |  Merchandise |  Supporting Vendors |  Chat 

Go Back   The National Lightning Owners Club Inc > The Trucks > Gen 2 Lightnings

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 01-22-2009, 09:04 PM   #1 (permalink)
Powered By Eaton!
 
Z7What's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: New Orleans, LA
iTrader: 1 / 100%
Send a message via AIM to Z7What
AFR What you should know.... LONG

PART 1
Quite a bit of emphasis is put on AFR or “Air to Fuel Ratio” on the Internet. With the emergence of ethanol blends such as E85 and the increasingly common E10 around town, any discussion AFR is not as straight forward as it would seem. AFR can only be calculated if one knows the stoich of the fuel. Most individuals do not fully understand tuning with alternative fuels and how wideband readings are affected. Some popular wideband tests could be improved from a more thorough understanding of the concepts we’re about to discuss in this two-part series.

One thing we should clear up first is the difference between your vehicles stock oxygen sensors (narrowband) and an aftermarket wideband sensor and controller. Your stock narrow band sensor is essentially a switch - it can tell you if you are higher or lower than a set point (a lambda of 1.00 - read further to understand what this is). A wideband sensor - and more importantly the controller driving it - is capable of interpreting a wide range of lambda, not just which side of a single fixed point you are on.

A discussion of widebands and air to fuel ratio must begin with an understanding of lambda (λ). So on to lambda… what is it?

Lambda is quite simply a multiplier used to determine how far off from the fuel’s stoich value you are. Lambda is the language spoken by all narrow and wideband oxygen sensors. When talking about premium unleaded gasoline, a value of around 14.64 parts of air to one part fuel is accepted as the (stoichiometric) mixture at which all fuel molecules are burned/oxidized with all oxygen molecules to form CO2 and H2O. It is generally assumed that a value of 14.64 is stoich for generic unleaded fuel which is not always the case.

Here are a few common fuel types and their approximate stoich value. Each of these stoich values are also represented as a lambda of 1.00:

* Unleaded 93 octane: 14.64
* E5 93 octane: 14.35
* E10 93 octane: 14.08
* E15 93 octane: 13.79
* VP C16: 14.77
* e85: 9.76
* e100: 9.00

Now say you want a richer mixture for a supercharged car under boost – typically I will command about 0.80 lambda. To get this into an air to fuel ratio you will take the stoichimetric value of your fuel (14.64 in this example) and multiply it by the lambda – 0.80 * 14.64 = 11.712:1. In order to use your O2 sensor and meter you must know the stoich point (14.64 used in the previous equation) if converting the O2 output to A/F and one can only use a wideband sensor for output not a narrow band sensor.

Let’s take it a bit further and check out the stock fuel table for a Shelby GT500. Understand this table is only used under certain throttle conditions but this is a good example to get you thinking…



Looking at this table, you’ll see RPM across the top and TP (throttle position) down the left. At 6000RPM and 800TP (floored) the PCM commands 0.819 lambda. What is 0.819 lambda? It is 14.64 & 0.819 = 11.99:1. The Ford PCM uses 14.64 as the stoichiometric value.

Now a caveat… just because you change this table does not mean the car will magically hit the lambda you command, in fact, there are quite a few other items that will add/subtract fueling commanded in this table. One of the many things I do while tuning your car is to make the desired fueling under all conditions match what is actually seen on the wideband, keeping in mind the various lambdas that need to be commanded during wide open throttle, cruising, idling, cold start, hot start, the list goes on.

Here’s the kicker, with the ethanol blends floating around (E5, E10, E20) the stoich of the fueling will change, changing what you see on the wideband. Scary? Yes possibly but that is why I wanted to show you a bit of what goes into properly calibrating a vehicle and what is taken into consideration, this is only the tip of the iceberg.

In my next article, the rubber meets the road. I will explain how you can datalog your air to fuel ratio/lambda, things to keep in mind while using widebands and lastly the effect of the fuel change we’ve seen here in Baton Rouge going from unleaded gasoline to an ethanol blend. For the curious I’ll also touch on my experiences with converting to e85 in non flex fuel vehicles, especially as they relate to the higher octane provided.

PART 2

In the last article I left you with some questions - with the changing stoich values for fuel, how do you know what your wideband should read? I also alluded to how fuel with different stoich values can lean out your vehicle. In this article we are going to nail down how to know that you can trust your wideband (or can you) and how to protect your vehicle when mixing in race fuels at the dragstrip. Just because it is a race fuel doesn’t mean it will give you additional safety!

So let’s setup a real world example. Say your vehicle is tuned for unleaded gasoline. It has a stoich point of 14.64:1. When you are cruising (termed “Closed Loop”) your vehicle is taking readings from the O2 sensors. The PCM will run a calculation to shoot fuel based upon its built in programming. The PCM then polls the O2 sensors after a short period (some longtubes need tuning for this delay because of how the O2 is moved) and measures the results of this calculation to see how its calculation worked out. These errors are collected and learned over time and a correction is applied to the calculation to keep things in check for fuel variations, changing conditions, aging sensors etc. If you are far enough out on your tune or a sensor the car will throw a check engine light along with a rich or lean code. Typically a vehicle can learn a 15% correction either way before throwing a light. When I tune a vehicle I shoot for no more than 3-5% correction in cruising conditions.

So say that your vehicle is perfectly tuned and the trims are within a few percent of each other. Now you get a tank of E10 which requires more fueling to make that same lambda of 1.00. Essentially when you fill up with E10 you have now leaned your car out. The closed loop correction will take care of you and enrichen the mixture back to a lambda of 1. The trims will be adding roughly 4% more fuel with the E10.

So with this learning things should always be kosher. Not quite… when you nail the skinny pedal you leave the happy world of closed loop. The vehicle now requires a mixture richer than stoich and the stock narrowbands cannot accurately read outside of a small range around a lambda of 1. Because of this you get no correction to the fueling, what is programmed in is what gets squirted out of the injectors. You can see why this might be bad if your car is run with a different fuel than it was programmed for. Some new cars can learn this and apply a correction. Most cannot.

This brings us to a discussion of wideband air to fuel meters. They are capable of reading outside a lambda of 1. Not all widebands are created equal. Not even close. Most consumer widebands use the Bosch LSU-4 sensor. It is a very cost effective sensor but over time as the sensor ages the readings can drift. When I dyno tune I use a sensor/controller combo that is proven accurate and does not exhibit this drifting phenomenon. While it works fine in a daily driver type scenario to get a sense of if things are going horribly wrong, on the dyno I have to trust what I am seeing - the Bosch sensor in my experience does not give me that warm fuzzy feeling.

Ok so we have a wideband controller and display, it says we are running 12.8:1 at wide open throttle. Is this correct? Is 12.8:1 really 12.8:1? What is stoich? To understand this you must first realize that the wideband reads in lambda and then multiplies the data by a hardcoded (or programmable on some) stoich value. This is important to know when you are using a wideband. Some widebands use a stoich of 14.7, some use 14.54, some 14.64. This will skew your numbers so keep it in mind. The error is not a huge deal but it is something you need to realize when tuning or watching your gauges. On your higher end widebands you are able to program the stoich point or forgo reading in AFR alltogether and instead just see the lambda values.

The short answer is to know the stoich of your fuel, educate the tune appropriately and then interpret the readings of your wideband with these things in mind.

So now let’s setup another scenario… you go to the race track and decide you want to mix in some race fuel for added safety. Going down the track you notice your tune that was dialed in at 12.8:1 is now running 13.8:1 on your wideband! What happened??? You’ll notice that the unleaded race fuels typically have a much different stoich value than the leaded fuels. Leaded fuels are normally quite close to the stoich of unleaded gas. Unleaded race fuels aren’t uncommon to have a stoich in the 13s, effectively leaning out your vehicle. If you have a particular fuel you are curious on the stoich of let me know and I will look it up for you.

Let’s take a final example. You have your vehicle tuned for unleaded gasoline with a stoich of 14.64:1. There are 3 gallons of this in the tank. You add in 5 gallons of Sunoco GT plus unleaded (112 octane) with a stoich of 13.8:1. Doing the math you now have a stoich value of roughly 14.11:1. Your car will be running just over half a point lean. It is not the octane that makes the difference but rather the changed stoich value. Keep this in mind.

There are still even more considerations when tuning in the fueling on your vehicle, these items just brush the surface of the larger picture but they are things I want every one of my customers to understand.

This article and the first post were written by Wes @ TPS which is a local performance shop.

A special thanks goes out to Michael Rauscher at L&M Engines for proofing and offering suggestions in the development of this article.

Wayne
__________________

2003 F-150 FX4 Powered by 2003 Lightning Engine #2005
AFCO H/E With Fans, Killer Chiller, Ported Throttle Body, Ported Plenum,
Ported C&L Elbow, Metco Idlers, 4# Lower Pulley, Bosch 255LPH Fuel Pump, 90MM MAF,
K&N Filter,EGR Delete, L&S Oil Separator, NGK TR6, Flex-A-Lite EFans, 170* T-Stat
Sooned To Be Tuned By Total Performance Solutions
Best 1/4 14.569@ 90.84MPH
Best 60' 2.08

Last edited by Z7What; 08-17-2009 at 08:09 PM..
Z7What is online now   Reply With Quote
Old 01-22-2009, 10:22 PM   #2 (permalink)
CORNFED
Paid Member
 
lightningkylej's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Oklahoma
Posts: 571
NLOC member #: 2739
View this user's gallery
iTrader: 0 / 0%
I will definately keep this thread stickied. I have converted my toys over to E-85 over the past few years. It is some great stuff other than the loss of fuel mileage. I have recently switched over to full E-85 in the Lightning. I am only getting about 7.5 to 8.0 mpg 98% in town driving over the past 600 or so miles. But I have to admit I am less hesitant to romp the go pedal than I am with pump gas in the tank. I was only getting 10 mpg in town before the swap with premium pump gas with a very light foot.
lightningkylej is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-22-2009, 10:23 PM   #3 (permalink)
475/530
 
johndeere185's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Farmington, MO
iTrader: 8 / 100%
I forget, did you have a stock block?
johndeere185 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-22-2009, 11:45 PM   #4 (permalink)
CORNFED
Paid Member
 
lightningkylej's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Oklahoma
Posts: 571
NLOC member #: 2739
View this user's gallery
iTrader: 0 / 0%
If you are asking me, no. I have patriot st 2 heads, comp st 2 cams, 8.6 probe pistons, scat rods, 6 lb lower, home ported blower, airiad intake, accufab sbtb, 1 3/4" pacesetters with custom dual 3" exhaust, and mafia with diablo tune by ABEL Racing of Midwest City, OK. Pre E-85 it made 446 hp 500 tq on 91 octane without the accufab which seems to help alot (picked up 2-3 psi with it). Haven't redynoed since the conversion. I probably will after I get the wedding over with next month, right before the tracks open back up.
lightningkylej is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-23-2009, 08:38 AM   #5 (permalink)
Registered User
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Savannah, Ga.
iTrader: 0 / 0%
Crap! Didn't realize you blew it up.... I've always liked your truck.....Like you, mine's a little different too.
diesel1 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-23-2009, 09:36 AM   #6 (permalink)
Registered User
Paid Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2000
Location: Rogers AR
Posts: 2,207
NLOC member #: 419
View this user's gallery
iTrader: 14 / 100%
Definiately a sticky!Very good info.for all to know and learn from!STan
__________________
NLOC Member;#419
Ruslow is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-23-2009, 04:10 PM   #7 (permalink)
Boosted by Whipple
Paid Member
 
Scuba-Matt's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: South East Florida
Posts: 4,149
NLOC member #: 2117
View this user's gallery
iTrader: 15 / 100%
Thats a great read
__________________
...........04 DSG, Built 9/02/03 #53/3781...........
............Tuned by JDM, 10.42 @129.72.............
......2007 Moroso Truck Series Champion......
Scuba-Matt is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-23-2009, 04:14 PM   #8 (permalink)
Registered User
 
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: Redding CA
iTrader: 5 / 100%
It would also be interesting to learn about the effects of winter formula oxygenated fuels and stoic A/F. I know it detonates alot easier than summer formula fuel, and not just due to colder air temps.
__________________
2000 #868 of 4966
Whipple 2.3, LFP CAI, 90mm MAF, TR6 gapped at .034, 2# lower 3.375 upper 15-17psi, ported stock TB, MAFia#2, predator, Snow Meth injetion, LFP 58" bars, 2400 stall, FTVB, DCC e-fan, 170 stat, 3ea-7" HE fans and I/C switch, magnaflow CB w/ bassani catless mids. 12.42@110
ducman is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-23-2009, 06:01 PM   #9 (permalink)
CORNFED
Paid Member
 
lightningkylej's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Oklahoma
Posts: 571
NLOC member #: 2739
View this user's gallery
iTrader: 0 / 0%
Quote:
Originally Posted by ducman View Post
It would also be interesting to learn about the effects of winter formula oxygenated fuels and stoic A/F. I know it detonates alot easier than summer formula fuel, and not just due to colder air temps.
Generally the winter E-85 mix is actually closer to E-70, especially in the northern states. The increased percentage of gasoline helps the vehicle start easier in colder climates. The summer mixes can be as high as 92-93% ethanol. Going from 50% E-85 to 100% E-85 I see about a 1.5 point difference on my wideband, or for example, my 50% tune with a 12.0 AFR will be 13.5 to 13.8 on 100% E-85.

I have run 50% E-85 with regular 87 octane gasoline in my old SRT-4 with the stock turbo cranking 20-21 psi without any detonation at all and no pulled timing.
lightningkylej is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-23-2009, 06:10 PM   #10 (permalink)
CORNFED
Paid Member
 
lightningkylej's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Oklahoma
Posts: 571
NLOC member #: 2739
View this user's gallery
iTrader: 0 / 0%
Quote:
Originally Posted by diesel1 View Post
Crap! Didn't realize you blew it up.... I've always liked your truck.....Like you, mine's a little different too.
Yea, it let go back in December on 2007. It wasn't down long. I had it back together in about 3 weeks. I had been stepping up on the power for about 3 years straight. At the end I was spraying a 135 shot and making 548 whp and 740 tq. Then, I decided to put on some LT's and dual 3". I made a few runs on the street with that setup on the spray and it felt really good. Took it to the dyno and it made 30 more HP and 40 more TQ. Then I wanted to see what it was making on the bottle but didn't get a pull completed before it let go. I guess that little bit extra finally over powered the stock rods. It threw three rods out the side of the block turning them back into dust and bent all the rest. I don't believe I had any detonation because all the pistons, valves and spark plugs look great other than a couple bent exhaust valves from the pistons disconnecting from the crank. That tune was on straight VP 110 with 10-12* of timing that I had been using forever.
lightningkylej is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-23-2009, 06:17 PM   #11 (permalink)
Powered By Eaton!
 
Z7What's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: New Orleans, LA
iTrader: 1 / 100%
Send a message via AIM to Z7What
Quote:
Originally Posted by johndeere185 View Post
I forget, did you have a stock block?
Yes

I also thing the the info in the first post would be added to a sticky.

Wayne
__________________

2003 F-150 FX4 Powered by 2003 Lightning Engine #2005
AFCO H/E With Fans, Killer Chiller, Ported Throttle Body, Ported Plenum,
Ported C&L Elbow, Metco Idlers, 4# Lower Pulley, Bosch 255LPH Fuel Pump, 90MM MAF,
K&N Filter,EGR Delete, L&S Oil Separator, NGK TR6, Flex-A-Lite EFans, 170* T-Stat
Sooned To Be Tuned By Total Performance Solutions
Best 1/4 14.569@ 90.84MPH
Best 60' 2.08
Z7What is online now   Reply With Quote
Old 02-10-2009, 08:43 PM   #12 (permalink)
Powered By Eaton!
 
Z7What's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: New Orleans, LA
iTrader: 1 / 100%
Send a message via AIM to Z7What
PART 2

In the last article I left you with some questions - with the changing stoich values for fuel, how do you know what your wideband should read? I also alluded to how fuel with different stoich values can lean out your vehicle. In this article we are going to nail down how to know that you can trust your wideband (or can you) and how to protect your vehicle when mixing in race fuels at the dragstrip. Just because it is a race fuel doesn’t mean it will give you additional safety!

So let’s setup a real world example. Say your vehicle is tuned for unleaded gasoline. It has a stoich point of 14.64:1. When you are cruising (termed “Closed Loop”) your vehicle is taking readings from the O2 sensors. The PCM will run a calculation to shoot fuel based upon its built in programming. The PCM then polls the O2 sensors after a short period (some longtubes need tuning for this delay because of how the O2 is moved) and measures the results of this calculation to see how its calculation worked out. These errors are collected and learned over time and a correction is applied to the calculation to keep things in check for fuel variations, changing conditions, aging sensors etc. If you are far enough out on your tune or a sensor the car will throw a check engine light along with a rich or lean code. Typically a vehicle can learn a 15% correction either way before throwing a light. When I tune a vehicle I shoot for no more than 3-5% correction in cruising conditions.

So say that your vehicle is perfectly tuned and the trims are within a few percent of each other. Now you get a tank of E10 which requires more fueling to make that same lambda of 1.00. Essentially when you fill up with E10 you have now leaned your car out. The closed loop correction will take care of you and enrichen the mixture back to a lambda of 1. The trims will be adding roughly 4% more fuel with the E10.

So with this learning things should always be kosher. Not quite… when you nail the skinny pedal you leave the happy world of closed loop. The vehicle now requires a mixture richer than stoich and the stock narrowbands cannot accurately read outside of a small range around a lambda of 1. Because of this you get no correction to the fueling, what is programmed in is what gets squirted out of the injectors. You can see why this might be bad if your car is run with a different fuel than it was programmed for. Some new cars can learn this and apply a correction. Most cannot.

This brings us to a discussion of wideband air to fuel meters. They are capable of reading outside a lambda of 1. Not all widebands are created equal. Not even close. Most consumer widebands use the Bosch LSU-4 sensor. It is a very cost effective sensor but over time as the sensor ages the readings can drift. When I dyno tune I use a sensor/controller combo that is proven accurate and does not exhibit this drifting phenomenon. While it works fine in a daily driver type scenario to get a sense of if things are going horribly wrong, on the dyno I have to trust what I am seeing - the Bosch sensor in my experience does not give me that warm fuzzy feeling.

Ok so we have a wideband controller and display, it says we are running 12.8:1 at wide open throttle. Is this correct? Is 12.8:1 really 12.8:1? What is stoich? To understand this you must first realize that the wideband reads in lambda and then multiplies the data by a hardcoded (or programmable on some) stoich value. This is important to know when you are using a wideband. Some widebands use a stoich of 14.7, some use 14.54, some 14.64. This will skew your numbers so keep it in mind. The error is not a huge deal but it is something you need to realize when tuning or watching your gauges. On your higher end widebands you are able to program the stoich point or forgo reading in AFR alltogether and instead just see the lambda values.

The short answer is to know the stoich of your fuel, educate the tune appropriately and then interpret the readings of your wideband with these things in mind.

So now let’s setup another scenario… you go to the race track and decide you want to mix in some race fuel for added safety. Going down the track you notice your tune that was dialed in at 12.8:1 is now running 13.8:1 on your wideband! What happened??? You’ll notice that the unleaded race fuels typically have a much different stoich value than the leaded fuels. Leaded fuels are normally quite close to the stoich of unleaded gas. Unleaded race fuels aren’t uncommon to have a stoich in the 13s, effectively leaning out your vehicle. If you have a particular fuel you are curious on the stoich of let me know and I will look it up for you.

Let’s take a final example. You have your vehicle tuned for unleaded gasoline with a stoich of 14.64:1. There are 3 gallons of this in the tank. You add in 5 gallons of Sunoco GT plus unleaded (112 octane) with a stoich of 13.8:1. Doing the math you now have a stoich value of roughly 14.11:1. Your car will be running just over half a point lean. It is not the octane that makes the difference but rather the changed stoich value. Keep this in mind.

There are still even more considerations when tuning in the fueling on your vehicle, these items just brush the surface of the larger picture but they are things I want every one of my customers to understand.

This article and the first post were written by Wes @ TPS which is a local performance shop.
__________________

2003 F-150 FX4 Powered by 2003 Lightning Engine #2005
AFCO H/E With Fans, Killer Chiller, Ported Throttle Body, Ported Plenum,
Ported C&L Elbow, Metco Idlers, 4# Lower Pulley, Bosch 255LPH Fuel Pump, 90MM MAF,
K&N Filter,EGR Delete, L&S Oil Separator, NGK TR6, Flex-A-Lite EFans, 170* T-Stat
Sooned To Be Tuned By Total Performance Solutions
Best 1/4 14.569@ 90.84MPH
Best 60' 2.08

Last edited by Z7What; 02-11-2009 at 05:48 PM..
Z7What is online now   Reply With Quote
Old 02-10-2009, 09:00 PM   #13 (permalink)
The L Doctor
 
Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: Pryor, OK
iTrader: 2 / 100%
Send a message via Yahoo to doctorjj
Here's the original blog that this info comes from.

Total Performance Solutions
__________________
2001 Silver L
Built motor (rebuilt by me), Patriot heads (fixed/redone with good components), 2.3 KB, 8 lb lower, 3.25 upper, Snow meth inj, BTS tranny, etc, etc.
Tuned by Sal @ PSP 542/575 street 602/671 race
doctorjj is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-10-2009, 09:03 PM   #14 (permalink)
Registered User
 
autenb's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Chesapeake, VA
iTrader: 0 / 0%
VERY VERY VERY good read. I've been trying to look up some stuff like this for a while and this is a very easy to read writeup. I wonder if most tuners tune for E10 these days... or what...
__________________
2003 DSG Lightning Build #1409
Performance:
JL Tuned/HC Racing Built 9.25:1 Longblock, Steigmeier Stg V Port, Ported C&L Truflow Plenum, LFP SBTB, C&L TruFlow Elbow, SCT BA2400 MAF, Siemsens 60# Injectors, JLP CAI, 2C FTVB, 6# (9") Lower, Optima Red Top, NGK TR6's (V-Power) gapped @ .033, Precision Fabrication Intercooler Reservoir, Triple-Pass Fluidyne H/E, Kooks LT's, JDM Mids w/ Hi-Flo Cats, Borla Catback, PCV Delete, EGR Delete, 4X4 Trans Pan, Nitto 555's on all 4 corners.
HP:509.7@4577 TQ: 569.5@4316 ON A MUSTANG DYNO
If you don't stand behind our troops, please feel free to stand in front of them.
autenb is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-10-2009, 09:44 PM   #15 (permalink)
SAL
yummm.......SRT-ee
 
SAL's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: NOLA
iTrader: 0 / 0%
Great read, Wayne.
Who is the author?





NM: a link was provided while I was reading. Thanks, doc.

Last edited by SAL; 02-10-2009 at 09:56 PM..
SAL is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:54 PM.


Powered by vBulletin®
Copyright ©2000 - 2009, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
SEO by vBSEO 3.2.0
Copyright NLOC, Inc. 2001-2009